Every search committee lives in a tension. The men it is talking to are serving other churches and need their names kept quiet. The congregation that appointed the committee wants to know what is going on. Lean too far toward secrecy and the church starts to feel managed. Lean too far toward openness and a good man withdraws because his elders heard about your search before he told them.
Both failures are common. Both are avoidable.
The Tension Every Committee Lives In
A pastor who takes your call is risking something. If word gets back to his church that he is “looking,” the trust he has built can erode in a week, even if he ultimately stays. He knows this. That is why experienced men ask about confidentiality before they ask about anything else, and why a committee that cannot answer well loses them.
At the same time, a congregation that hears nothing for six months fills the silence with its own stories. People assume the committee is stuck, or divided, or hiding something. Trust leaks out of the church quietly, and by the time a candidate is presented, half the congregation has decided the process was flawed.
What You Owe the Candidate
You owe him a clear promise and the discipline to keep it. The promise is simple: no one outside the committee will hear his name until he agrees to be presented. No “just the elders.” No “my wife, but she won’t tell anyone.” No reference calls to anyone at his current church without his explicit permission. Write it down and have every committee member sign it, not because they are untrustworthy, but because a signed sheet is easier to remember at a church potluck than a verbal nod in a meeting.
One caution: do not promise what you cannot deliver. If your church’s bylaws require the deacons to approve a candidate before the congregation sees him, tell the candidate that at the first conversation. He can decide whether to proceed. What he cannot forgive is finding out later.
What You Owe the Congregation
You owe them the process, not the names. Members do not need to know who you are talking to. They need to know that you are working, praying, and making progress, and they need to hear it from the committee rather than from the rumor mill.
A monthly update, two minutes from the pulpit or three paragraphs in the bulletin, does the job. Where we are in the process. How many men we have talked to, in round numbers. What we are praying for. What the congregation can do to help. The content is modest. The effect on trust is large.
Want a buffer between your committee and the candidates?
When Premier runs a search, candidates deal with us until they are ready to be presented, which keeps their names safe and your committee free to focus on evaluation. There is no cost to an initial conversation.
Practices That Protect Both
- One point of contact. One committee member handles all communication with candidates. Fewer people with a candidate’s phone number means fewer chances of a slip.
- No names in email. Refer to candidates by number or by initials in anything written. Emails get forwarded. Minutes get left on a counter.
- Meet away from the building. A committee that gathers at church on a Tuesday night will be asked on Wednesday what they talked about.
- Hold references until late. Reference checks are the most common leak, because a reference is often a friend of someone at the candidate’s church. Do them when you are down to two or three men, with the candidate’s permission for each call.
- Decide the presentation plan early. When you reach a finalist, how and when does the congregation learn his name? Agree on this before you have a finalist, so the decision is not made in a rush.
When Something Leaks
Sometimes it happens anyway. If a candidate’s name gets out, call him the same day. Tell him exactly what was said and to whom. Apologize without excuses. Then let him decide what he needs to do. Some men will withdraw, and the committee must accept that graciously. Others will appreciate the honesty and stay in. What no man will forgive is learning about the leak from someone other than you.
And if the leak came from inside the committee, deal with it. A committee member who cannot keep a confidence should not be on a search committee, however well-liked he is. The church’s witness to the men it is calling matters more than anyone’s feelings.