Search Planning

Bivocational or Full-Time? Deciding Before You Post

Thousands of churches are asking this question. Here is how to answer it honestly, before the posting goes out.

Premier Church Staffing · September 2026 · 7 min read

More churches than ever are asking whether their next pastor should be bivocational. Some ask because the budget will not stretch. Some ask because the church is small and always has been. A few ask because a well-meaning member heard it is the future of the church and wants to be ahead of it.

Whatever the reason, the decision needs to be made before the posting goes out, not after the first candidate asks. Committees that leave it open end up with a listing that attracts neither the full-time man who needs to support his family nor the bivocational man who needs to know the church understands what he can and cannot do.

The Question Behind the Question

“Can we afford a full-time pastor?” is usually a stand-in for a harder question: “What is this church able and willing to do?” A congregation of sixty that gives sacrificially can often support a modest full-time salary. A congregation of one hundred fifty that has grown comfortable sometimes cannot. The number in the pews matters less than the heart behind the giving.

So before anyone talks about pay, the leadership should be able to answer three things plainly. What is our actual giving over the last three years, not our hope? What do we spend on the building and programs, and could any of it move? And are we willing to ask the congregation to give more for a shepherd? If the honest answer to the last one is no, you have learned something important about the church, not just the budget.

Do the Math Honestly

A full-time pastor in most of the country needs a package that lets his family live without a second income, and that package includes more than salary: housing or a housing allowance, health coverage, retirement, and the employer share of Social Security that pastors pay themselves. Our salary benchmark gives you real numbers by church size and region. Use them.

Then look at your budget with that number in it. If the church can meet it with a reasonable stretch, call a full-time man. If the gap is wide and would require the church to spend its reserves within two years, you are looking at a bivocational call whether you like the word or not. Hoping the right man will “grow the church” into the salary is how churches burn through savings and then lose the pastor anyway.

Hoping the right man will grow the church into his salary is how churches spend their reserves and then lose the pastor anyway.

What You Are Asking of the Man

A bivocational pastor works two jobs. He prepares sermons at night. He makes hospital visits on his lunch break. He will not be at the building forty hours a week, and if the church expects him to be, he will fail and the church will blame him for it.

Churches that do well with bivocational pastors decide in advance what the pastor is for: preaching, teaching, shepherding the sick and the grieving, and training leaders. Everything else, the building, the bulletin, the youth lock-in, the website, belongs to the members. If your congregation is not ready to take those things on, do not call a bivocational man and then wonder why they are not getting done.

Not sure which model fits your church?

We have walked small churches through this exact decision, and we will tell you honestly which men will consider your call. There is no cost to an initial conversation.

Schedule a free consultation

Three Models That Work

  • Full-time, modest package. The church commits to a real salary at the benchmark for its size and region and asks the congregation to give toward it. This is the right answer more often than committees think.
  • Bivocational by design. The pastor has a stable outside vocation, the church pays a meaningful part-time salary, and expectations are written down. Many of the healthiest small churches in America run this way.
  • Full-time with a runway. The church can fund three years at full salary and has a plan for year four. The pastor knows the plan. This works only when everyone is honest about what “the plan” actually is.

What does not work is the fourth model, the one nobody chooses on purpose: posting for a full-time pastor, discovering during negotiations that the church cannot pay for one, and losing the best candidate while the committee scrambles.

Decide, Then Write the Posting

Once the leadership has done the math and chosen a model, say so in the posting. “Full-time, with housing and benefits.” Or: “Bivocational, with a part-time salary and a congregation that carries the ministries of the church.” Either sentence will draw the right men and spare the wrong ones a wasted application. Vagueness draws everyone and serves no one.

And remember that the model you choose today is not forever. Churches grow, give more, and move a bivocational man to full-time all the time. Start with what is true now. God is perfectly able to change it.

Your church does not have to search alone.

Whether you are searching for a Senior Pastor, Worship Pastor, Youth Pastor, or ministry staff, Premier Church Staffing can help you move forward with wisdom and confidence.